What commercial property owners in Wollongong and Newcastle can learn from long-term vacancy.
Some commercial buildings were exceptional in their time.
They were well designed, well built, and played an important role in their local community for decades. Many still hold enormous sentimental value for the people who bought them, operated from them, or inherited them.
But commercial property does not stand still.
Tenant demand changes. Consumer behaviour changes. Building requirements change. Compliance expectations change. And over the past five years, COVID has played a significant role in reshaping demand across retail, hospitality and industrial property.
Smaller retail and hospitality spaces have become harder to lease in some locations, while demand has strengthened for larger, more flexible industrial-style premises that can support storage, logistics, production, trade use and modern business operations.
This creates a difficult question for owners:
What happens when a once-successful commercial asset is no longer fit for purpose?
The case study: a 50-year-old commercial strata asset.
Comelli Commercial manages a commercial asset within a strata building made up of ten commercial units.
Most of the units were originally designed for food and beverage operators. The building itself is around 50 years old and, in its day, was an award-winning development.
Structurally, the building remains solid. It was built well. It has served its owners and occupants for many years. It has history, character and a strong location.
But the current commercial reality is very different.
The site now requires constant attention across roofs, external areas, grease traps, services and general maintenance. These are not unusual issues for an older commercial building, but they become more significant when the income profile of the asset no longer supports the ongoing cost and effort required to maintain it.
The bigger issue is tenant demand.
The individual shops are no longer aligned with what modern hospitality operators need.
They are small. They are constrained. They lack sufficient space for cool rooms, storage, preparation areas and back-of-house facilities that are now essential for many successful food and beverage businesses.
A café, restaurant or takeaway operator today is not simply looking for a shopfront. They need operational space. They need services that work. They need access, storage, preparation flow, ventilation, waste management and a layout that helps the business trade efficiently.
When the premises cannot support that, the pool of suitable tenants becomes smaller.
The result: more than 50% vacancy for five years
The outcome in this case is self-evident.
More than 50% of the site is vacant, and it has remained that way for the past five years.
That is not a short vacancy period. That is not a minor leasing issue.That is a sign that the market may have moved beyond the current form of the asset.
In our view, the long-term outlook is unlikely to change while the property remains as it is.
Quality tenants are increasingly seeking modern premises with the space, services, access, amenity and efficiency required to operate successfully. They do not want to take on the additional burden of ageing infrastructure, constant maintenance or a tenancy that restricts their ability to trade.
This is the point many owners find difficult to confront.
A property can be well located and still be hard to lease.
A building can be structurally sound and still be commercially outdated.
An asset can have a proud history and still need a new future.
When vacancy is not just a leasing problem
In commercial property management, vacancy is often treated as a marketing or leasing issue.
Sometimes it is.
The rent may be too high. The advertising may be weak. The property may need minor works. The agent may need to reposition the listing. The incentives may need to be reviewed.
But sometimes vacancy is telling a deeper story.
If a property has been vacant for a long period, especially in a market where other properties are leasing, the issue may not be exposure. It may be suitability.
That is when owners need to look beyond the question, “Why has this not leased?”
The better question is:
“Does this property still suit the tenants we are trying to attract?”
For older commercial and retail assets in Wollongong and Newcastle, this question is becoming more important. Both markets have changing commercial needs, growing populations, pressure for housing supply, and demand for more flexible premises.
That does not mean every older commercial building should be redeveloped. But it does mean every long-term vacancy should be reviewed properly.
Refurbishment, repositioning or redevelopment?
When a commercial property is no longer performing, there are usually several possible paths.
The first is refurbishment.
This may involve improving the presentation, upgrading services, resolving maintenance issues, modernising amenities or making the tenancy more attractive to current market expectations.
The second is repositioning.
This may mean changing the target tenant, adjusting the permitted use, splitting or combining tenancies, reviewing the rental expectation, or marketing the property to a different type of operator.
The third is a change of use.
Some buildings no longer work for their original purpose, but may work well for professional services, medical, allied health, showroom, office, training, community use or other commercial categories.
The fourth is redevelopment.
This is not always the first answer, but in some cases it becomes the highest and best outcome.
In this particular case, the site is now ripe for redevelopment.
The location is excellent. It represents a genuine opportunity to unlock value for the owners while also contributing to much-needed housing in a central and well-connected area.
The challenge: numbers versus emotion
Comelli Commercial worked with developers to bring strong offers to the lot owners.
Many of the owners are original owners. They have no debt. They have a deep emotional attachment to the property. They also have a strong belief that further uplift may still be possible.
That emotional connection is understandable.
Commercial assets often represent decades of ownership, memories, personal history and family decisions. For some owners, the property is not just an investment. It is part of their life.
But commercial property still needs to be assessed commercially.
In this case, the numbers told a compelling story.
Every owner stood to achieve a considerable profit uplift. In many cases, the sale proceeds could have been reinvested conservatively, even in the bank, and produced a better return than the shops were currently generating in rent.
Despite this, the owners were not ready to proceed.
They continue to wait for a sale price they cannot clearly articulate.
Meanwhile, the property remains more than 50% vacant while still carrying outgoings, maintenance costs and the opportunity cost of underperformance.
This is not an isolated situation
Across Wollongong, Newcastle and many regional commercial markets, there are buildings facing similar pressure.
They may be well located.
They may have history.
They may have been successful for many years.
But if they no longer meet the needs of modern tenants, vacancy becomes harder to solve and value becomes harder to protect.
This is especially relevant for older retail strips, hospitality precincts, mixed-use buildings, strata commercial assets and small-format commercial spaces that were designed for a different era of trade.
The issue is not that these properties have no value.
Often, the opposite is true.
The land, location and redevelopment potential may be extremely valuable. But that value may not be realised while the owners are focused only on trying to replace the previous type of tenant.
A vacant building is not always a failed asset.
Sometimes it is simply an asset waiting for its next chapter.
The importance of a commercial property audit
The key is to identify the issue early.
A proper commercial property audit can help owners understand why a building is not leasing and what options may be available.
This may include reviewing:
Current vacancy and leasing history
Market rent expectations
Tenant demand in the local area
Building condition and recurring maintenance issues
Services, access and operational limitations
Suitability for the intended tenant type
Possible refurbishment or repositioning options
Alternative commercial uses
Redevelopment potential
Likely return compared with the current holding position
For owners in Wollongong, Newcastle, the Illawarra and the Hunter, this kind of review can be especially valuable when a property has been sitting vacant, partially vacant or underperforming for an extended period.
The audit is not about forcing one answer.
Sometimes the right answer is to lease the property differently.
Sometimes it is to invest in improvements.
Sometimes it is to change the use.
Sometimes it is to sell.
And sometimes, the highest and best outcome is redevelopment.
The point is to make that decision with clarity, not sentiment alone.
Commercial property management is about more than collecting rent
Commercial property management is not just about collecting rent, arranging maintenance or finding tenants.
Good commercial property management requires a clear view of the asset’s long-term position.
Is the building still competitive?
Are the tenancies still suitable?
Are maintenance costs starting to outweigh income?
Is the vacancy temporary, or structural?
Is the property being held because it is commercially sensible, or because the owners are emotionally attached to a previous version of the asset?
These are not always easy questions, but they are important ones.
Because the longer a commercial property remains underperforming, the harder it can be to protect value.
Is your commercial property still fit for purpose?
If you own a commercial building in Wollongong, Newcastle, the Illawarra or the Hunter that has been vacant for some time, it may be worth asking whether the issue is truly the leasing campaign, or whether the asset itself needs to be reviewed.
The market may have changed.
The tenant profile may have changed.
The building may need refurbishment, repositioning or redevelopment.
Or there may be a simpler issue that can be corrected with the right commercial advice.
Comelli Commercial can undertake a free commercial property audit to identify why your property is not leasing and what options may be available.
A vacant building is not always the end of the asset’s value.
Sometimes it is the beginning of its next chapter.
If your commercial or industrial property has been sitting vacant, partially vacant or underperforming, contact Comelli Commercial to arrange a free audit.
We can review the property, the lease position, the tenant demand and the available options, then provide practical advice on the best next step.
A landlord replaced an air-conditioning system within five years, despite the tenant being responsible for maintenance. When Christina Comelli reviewed the situation, she identified what the previous managing agent had overlooked. A commercial lease can appear...
It started with an unusually high water bill. Christina Comelli spotted an unexpected charge of $754.15, questioned the contractor responsible and uncovered a servicing failure that would cost the landlord even more. By October, the unnecessary charges had reached $1,542.13. Comelli pursued the matter until the contractor agreed to reimburse the owner.
An old trust deed, decades of property ownership and a tax liability nobody had thought to question. A routine management review by Comelli Commercial uncovered a problem that professional advisers had overlooked for years. The property had been in the family since...
When a preschool owner called Christina Comelli to ask about leasing her premises, she had no idea the conversation would lead to a potential $550,000 business sale, a new source of rental income and a property investment opportunity worth considerably more than...
Ten years of construction costs, funding costs and yields – and why a built asset is looking better than a building site Every property investment ultimately rests on three numbers: what it costs to create or acquire the asset, what it costs to fund it, and what it...
Commercial and industrial versus residential: total returns 2016–2026, and why the tax reforms stretch the gap further Total returns (income plus capital growth) for commercial & industrial vs residential property, 2016–2026. Indicative national series. What...
What the 2026 negative gearing, CGT and SMSF borrowing reforms mean - and why commercial and industrial property now deserves a closer look In the space of six weeks, the federal government rewrote three of the pillars that Australian residential property...
Commercial property management is often misunderstood as a purely administrative service. Landlords tend to think of it as merely rent collection, tenant communication and lease paperwork. But good commercial property management can do much more than that. When a...
How early disclosure, strong due diligence preparation and commercial transparency can protect the value of a business or property sale Late last year, one of the largest proposed takeovers in Australian corporate history moved close to completion before the buyer...