A landlord replaced an air-conditioning system within five years, despite the tenant being responsible for maintenance. When Christina Comelli reviewed the situation, she identified what the previous managing agent had overlooked.
A commercial lease can appear perfectly adequate until something goes wrong.
For one commercial property owner, that moment came when an air-conditioning system in his restaurant property needed replacing within five years of installation.
The tenant was responsible for maintaining the equipment. The lease said so.
What the agreement didn’t adequately explain was how that responsibility should be carried out.
When the owner approached Christina Comelli, Principal of Comelli Commercial, she identified a shortcoming in how the lease had been prepared and managed. She also raised an important consideration concerning the tenant’s upcoming lease renewal option.
By the end of their conversation, the owner had something to say:
“I wish I’d found you years ago.”
He subsequently appointed Comelli Commercial to manage his property.
The experience illustrates why choosing an experienced commercial property manager matters, particularly for landlords who rely on their managing agent to identify risks before they become expensive problems.
The problem: an air-conditioning system replaced within five years
The property was occupied by a restaurant.
The landlord had installed an air-conditioning system, with responsibility for its maintenance assigned to the tenant under the commercial lease.
Yet within five years, the landlord had found himself replacing the equipment.
When Christina examined the circumstances, she identified an important omission.
Although the lease assigned maintenance responsibility to the tenant, it did not adequately specify what maintenance was required or how frequently it should be performed.
This was something the previous managing agent should have identified when providing instructions to the solicitor preparing the lease.
It is an important distinction.
A lease that identifies who is responsible for an asset is not necessarily a lease that adequately protects that asset.
The absence of detailed maintenance requirements does not, by itself, establish what caused the air-conditioning system to fail. However, it can make maintenance obligations more difficult to monitor and assess.
And that is precisely where experienced commercial property management can make a difference.
What should a commercial lease say about air-conditioning maintenance?
Commercial property leases should clearly define the maintenance and repair obligations agreed between landlord and tenant, subject to applicable legislation.
The NSW Small Business Commissioner’s Retail Tenancy Guide specifically identifies the importance of clarifying responsibility for repairs and maintenance, including air-conditioning equipment.
Depending on the premises, equipment and negotiated arrangements, a lease may need to address:
- Servicing frequency: How often must the system be inspected and professionally serviced?
- Routine maintenance: Are tasks such as cleaning or replacing filters required at specified intervals?
- Responsibility: Who arranges and pays for servicing, repairs and replacement?
- Maintenance records: What documentation must the tenant provide to demonstrate that servicing has occurred?
- Monitoring: How will the landlord or managing agent verify compliance with agreed obligations?
In this particular case, Christina identified the importance of providing practical instructions to the solicitor, including consideration of quarterly servicing and filter cleaning every six months, where appropriate for the system.
These are examples rather than universal servicing requirements. Actual maintenance schedules should reflect the equipment manufacturer’s recommendations, technical advice and applicable obligations.
The underlying principle is straightforward: a maintenance clause needs to be sufficiently specific to be understood, monitored and applied.
What the previous managing agent overlooked
A commercial lease is a legal document prepared by a solicitor.
But a solicitor also relies on appropriate instructions from the people who understand the property and how it operates.
An experienced commercial property manager can help identify the practical issues that need to be addressed during lease preparation or negotiation.
They understand the property’s physical assets, operational requirements and recurring maintenance considerations.
In Christina’s assessment, the previous managing agent had failed to identify the need for more specific air-conditioning maintenance provisions and instruct the solicitor accordingly.
That omission became particularly significant when the landlord faced the replacement of the system.
The case highlights an important distinction between routine property administration and proactive management.
Routine administration may involve collecting rent, organising repairs and responding to tenant enquiries.
Proactive commercial property management also involves reviewing obligations, identifying potential risks, monitoring important dates and communicating with landlords before decisions become urgent.
For owners considering a change of managing agent, these are important questions to ask.
A second consideration: the tenant’s lease renewal option
During the same conversation, the property owner raised another question.
His tenant had an upcoming option to renew the lease.
Could the landlord change the terms and conditions when the tenant exercised that option?
Christina explained why the timing and conditions of the option were important.
Generally, when a tenant validly exercises a contractual option to renew, they are entitled to renew on the terms previously agreed, subject to any changes provided for in the lease.
A renewal option is not necessarily an opportunity for the landlord to renegotiate the entire agreement.
The NSW Small Business Commissioner explains how lease options work, including the importance of complying with the option exercise period and the agreed renewal terms.
In this case, Christina discussed the tenant’s defined option window and the implications if that window passed without the option being validly exercised.
Depending on the agreement and applicable law, that circumstance could create an opportunity to negotiate a new lease on different terms.
Christina recommended that the landlord monitor the relevant dates and consider his position if the option was not exercised.
The discussion demonstrated the value of understanding not only what a lease says, but also when its provisions may affect a landlord’s negotiating position.
Lease options can have significant legal consequences. Whether an option has been validly exercised, and what rights remain after a deadline passes, must be assessed against the specific agreement and applicable law.
“I wish I’d found you years ago.”
That was the owner’s response after discussing the property with Christina.
He had approached Comelli Commercial with a management concern and discovered that there were important questions worth asking about both his property’s maintenance arrangements and its upcoming lease renewal.
He subsequently appointed Comelli Commercial as his managing agent.
For Christina, the experience reinforced something fundamental about commercial property management.
The value of an experienced agent is not always measured by what they do when something goes wrong.
Often, it is found in the problems they identify before anyone else notices them.
This is not the only example of that approach at Comelli Commercial.
In another documented case, Christina questioned a commercial property’s water bill and identified $1,542.13 in charges that should not have been there.
In a separate management review, Comelli identified a land tax issue costing a longstanding property owner more than $17,000 annually, leading to specialist legal advice about the trust’s tax treatment.
Different properties. Different circumstances.
The common thread is the importance of examining the details rather than assuming that existing arrangements are working as intended.
What should you expect from a good commercial property manager?
Whether you own a retail premises, office, warehouse or other commercial investment property, a managing agent should provide more than rent collection and routine administration.
A thorough management approach should consider the following.
1. Commercial lease obligations
Are maintenance and repair responsibilities clearly documented? Are obligations being monitored, and are potential ambiguities identified for legal review?
2. Lease expiry dates and renewal options
Does your agent maintain accurate records of lease dates, option windows and notice requirements? Are you informed of significant decisions in sufficient time to obtain professional advice?
3. Rent increases and market reviews
Are contractual increases and market review provisions properly tracked? Is your property’s rental position reviewed against the terms of its lease?
4. Outgoings and operating expenses
Are expenses being checked, recorded and recovered where permitted under the agreement and applicable law? Are unusual charges being questioned?
5. Communication and commercial judgement
Does your property manager explain potential issues and available options, or do you generally hear from them only when something requires immediate attention?
These questions provide a useful starting point for assessing whether your property is receiving the level of oversight it deserves.
Commercial property management in Wollongong, the Illawarra and Newcastle
For landlords seeking a commercial property manager in Wollongong, across the Illawarra or in Newcastle, local market knowledge is important, but so is the ability to interpret the financial and operational arrangements affecting each asset.
Comelli Commercial provides commercial property management services across Wollongong, Newcastle and surrounding NSW regions.
Established in 1967, Comelli is a multigenerational commercial real estate and business brokerage with offices in Wollongong and Newcastle East.
Led by Principal Christina Comelli, the agency works with commercial property owners on leasing, property management and reviews of existing management arrangements.
Its approach considers the relationship between commercial leases, expenses, rent reviews, operational obligations and long-term asset performance.
Landlords can also explore Comelli’s case study of a commercial lease oversight with potentially significant financial consequences to understand why lease structures and renewal dates deserve ongoing attention.
Frequently asked questions about commercial property management
Who is responsible for air-conditioning maintenance in a commercial lease?
Responsibility depends on the lease terms and applicable law. A commercial lease may assign routine air-conditioning maintenance to the tenant while allocating some repairs or replacement obligations differently. Owners should have their agreements reviewed by a suitably qualified legal adviser where responsibilities are unclear.
Can a landlord change the terms when a tenant renews a commercial lease?
Not automatically. A validly exercised renewal option generally entitles the tenant to renewal according to the terms already agreed. The outcome depends on the lease and applicable law. If an option is not validly exercised, there may be an opportunity to negotiate new terms, subject to the parties’ legal rights.
How do I know if my commercial property manager is doing a good job?
Look beyond whether rent is collected on time. Consider whether your agent tracks lease obligations, renewal options, rent reviews, operating expenses and maintenance requirements, communicates potential issues early and provides clear reporting.
Where can I find a commercial property manager in Wollongong or Newcastle?
Comelli Commercial offers commercial property management services in Wollongong, the Illawarra, Newcastle and surrounding NSW regions. The agency provides a free lease performance audit for landlords who want to review their existing arrangements before deciding whether to change managers.
Is your current commercial property manager overlooking something important?
The landlord in this case had a managing agent.
He had a commercial lease.
He had a tenant responsible for maintaining the air conditioning.
What he didn’t have was sufficient clarity about how that responsibility should be carried out.
It was only after speaking with Christina Comelli that he identified the importance of those missing details and considered the implications of an upcoming lease renewal.
Good commercial property management is not simply about administering a property. It is about understanding what the landlord needs to protect, recognising potential problems and knowing when to act.
If you own a commercial investment property in Wollongong, the Illawarra, Newcastle or surrounding NSW regions, Comelli Commercial offers a free, no-obligation lease performance audit.
The review considers areas such as lease dates and options, rent reviews, outgoings, management arrangements and potential opportunities to improve oversight.
There is no obligation to change managing agents.
Request your FREE Commercial Lease Performance Audit
Or contact Christina Comelli and the team to discuss your commercial property.
Comelli Commercial | Commercial Property Management
Wollongong: Suite 2, 72–76 Crown Street, Wollongong NSW 2500
Newcastle: 58 Bolton Street, Newcastle East NSW 2300
Phone: (02) 4204 8118
Disclaimer: This article provides general information only and does not constitute legal, taxation or financial advice. The case study reflects the circumstances described by Christina Comelli. It does not establish the cause of the equipment failure or liability for its replacement. Maintenance obligations and lease renewal rights vary depending on the agreement, applicable legislation and individual circumstances. The NSW retail leasing guidance linked above applies to leases covered by the relevant retail leasing framework and should not be assumed to govern every commercial lease. Property owners should seek appropriate professional advice.